When choosing between SPC (Stone Polymer Composite) flooring and waterproof laminate flooring, it’s important to understand their differences in durability, water resistance, and overall performance. Both options are excellent for modern homes and businesses, but the right choice depends on your specific needs.
1. Composition and Waterproofing Methods
- SPC Flooring: Made from a blend of limestone powder, plastic stabilizers, and polymers, SPC flooring has a rigid core that makes it highly durable, waterproof, and dimensionally stable.
-
Waterproof Laminate Flooring: Laminates achieve waterproofing through one of two primary methods:
- Method 1: Making the joints waterproof by designing them to be extremely tight and, in some cases, adding a special coating to prevent water penetration.
- Method 2: Using a core material with a swelling rate of less than 5%, meaning it resists water absorption and does not expand when exposed to moisture.
- Some premium brands, like McMillan, use both methods to maximize waterproofing capabilities, making their laminate floors highly resistant to water damage.
2. Water Resistance
- SPC Flooring: Completely 100% waterproof, making it suitable for high-moisture areas like bathrooms, kitchens, and basements. It will not swell or warp when exposed to water.
- Waterproof Laminate: Highly water-resistant due to advanced waterproofing technologies but not fully waterproof. While it can handle spills and moisture better than regular laminate, prolonged exposure to standing water may eventually cause swelling in lower-quality brands.
🔹 Best for moisture-prone areas: SPC
3. Durability and Scratch Resistance
- SPC Flooring: Highly durable and impact-resistant. However, SPC can be more prone to scratches from sharp objects due to its rigid core and wear layer.
- Waterproof Laminate: Has a more scratch-resistant aluminum oxide wear layer, making it superior against scratches from furniture, pet claws, and daily wear and tear.
🔹 Best for scratch resistance: Waterproof Laminate
4. Comfort and Feel Underfoot
- SPC Flooring: Feels slightly harder underfoot due to its rigid core.
- Waterproof Laminate: Offers a slightly more cushioned feel, but overall, the difference in comfort between the two is minimal.
🔹 Tied: Comfort depends on the underlayment used.
5. Temperature and Sunlight Stability
- SPC Flooring: More dimensionally stable, meaning it won’t expand or contract as much with temperature changes.
- Waterproof Laminate: Newer waterproof laminates are highly resistant to temperature changes and UV exposure, making them an equally good or better choice for sunrooms and areas with direct sunlight.
🔹 Best for sunrooms: Tied (both SPC and waterproof laminate perform well).
6. Impact Resistance
- SPC Flooring: Due to its stone-based core, SPC flooring is highly impact-resistant and can handle heavy furniture and foot traffic without denting.
- Waterproof Laminate: Also impact-resistant, but in some cases, SPC’s rigid core may be even more resistant to dents and pressure.
🔹 Best for impact resistance: SPC (slightly better).
7. Installation
- SPC Flooring: Both SPC and waterproof laminate use a floating, click-lock system, making installation DIY-friendly. However, SPC can sometimes be thinner, meaning it may need additional subfloor leveling.
- Waterproof Laminate: Usually thicker than SPC, which makes it more forgiving if the installer does not level the subfloor properly. Issues from an uneven subfloor may still arise, but they typically become noticeable several years later rather than during installation.
🔹 More forgiving for not perfectly leveled floors: Waterproof Laminate
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose SPC if:
✅ You need 100% waterproof flooring for areas like bathrooms, laundry rooms, or basements.
✅ You want maximum impact resistance for high-traffic areas or commercial use.
✅ You need stability in temperature changes and minimal expansion/contraction.
Choose Waterproof Laminate if:
✅ You want the most scratch-resistant option, especially for homes with pets or kids.
✅ You prefer a more realistic wood look and texture.
✅ You are installing in a sunroom or area with direct sunlight exposure.
✅ You need a flooring option that is more forgiving for minor subfloor imperfections.
Both options are great, but the best choice depends on your specific needs.
Final Verdict
💧 For water resistance → SPC wins
🛡️ For scratch resistance → Waterproof Laminate wins
🪵 For best wood-like appearance → Waterproof Laminate wins
🧱 For impact resistance → SPC wins
🌞 For sunrooms → Both perform well
🛠️ More forgiving for not perfectly leveled floors → Waterproof Laminate wins